Thursday, November 3, 2011

I Offended Daylin Leach: Good.

It seems I struck a nerve with State Senator Daylin Leach when I recently suggested that when it comes helping black kids escape failing public schools he is much like Alabama Gov. George Wallace standing in the school house door circa 1963.

In a letter to the editor in today's Daily Times, Leach professes to be heartily offended by my "inflammatory" comparison. I don't blame him. But then, it wasn't meant to be flattering.

Sen. Leach was the leading opponent of "opportunity scholarships" to allow some of Pennsylvania's poorest black children to escape some of the state's worst and most violent schools.

Mr. Leach attempts to find cover in the fact that such scholarships are opposed by many "prominent" black leaders, including civil rights hero Rep. John Lewis. He points out that some 38 out of 39 members of the Congressional Black Caucus voted against a federally funded scholarship program in Washington, D.C. effectively killing it, along with the hopes and dreams of hundreds of poor black families there.

That CBC members are more concerned with pleasing their well-heeled supporters in National Education Association than helping these inner-city families is certainly no credit to them. The NEA and other teachers' unions contribute millions to Democratic politicians at the state and federal levels to protect a public education system that has devolved into a protection racket for mediocre teachers and failing schools. And Lewis doesn't even have Leach's excuse that the money for those scholarships was taken from the budgets of those lousy schools.

In comparing him to George Wallace, Leach says that I "essentially called" him "a racist." No. I simply pointed out that his posturing on the issue, if it had been effective, would have prevented a decent number of poor black kids a chance at a decent education.

But it is ironic that a civil rights advocate like Leach has this in common with a racial bigot like George Wallace.

Leach claims that there has been "dramatic improvement" in test scores and 25 percent reduction in the achievement gap between the richest and poorest schools thanks to increased government spending. Please!

According to the National Center on Education Statistics as of 2009
"Pennsylvania has one of the largest gaps between White and African American students in fourth grade reading scores, a 33-point gap that has not narrowed much since 1992.

Black students in Pennsylvania score below the national average for Blacks, while Whites scores above the national average for Whites. A pretty glaring reality -- White students in Pennsylvania score about the same as those in Virginia, but Black students here score 13 points below Black students in the heart of the Old Confederacy.
Now, there's something Sen. Leach and we all can be proud of.

In any case, schools that show the sort of "dramatic improvement," Leach dreams about are not included in the bill. It's only truly failing schools from which these kids will be helped to flee.

But I am glad to see that Sen. Leach is against "race-baiting," even if he misattributes it to me. Maybe he'll have a word with some of his fellow liberals, like Rev. Jim Ley, who throw around the word "racist" so recklessly.

Lastly, the one thing Leach is right about is that comparing liberals like him to George Wallace in the schoolhouse door is not original to me. But it must be the first time he personally felt the sting of that observation.

I guess it smarts. It should.

The comparison stands.

UPDATE: Here's the D.C. Opportunity Scholarship program killed by John Lewis and his fellow Black Caucus members with the help of the President of the United States. A few less "prominent" black folks from that community would like to know "Why?"

3 Comments:

Blogger jake said...

A politician named "Leach"... talk about destiny.
Reminds me of Curly of the 3 Stooges playing a lawyer "I. Fleecum".

November 3, 2011 at 12:12 PM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I did my best to see what the demographics are of Sen. Leach's district but could not get any statistics... But considering the municipalites he represents (please see http://www.senatorleach.com/district/municipalities.htm ) one can surmise that he speaks from his heart, not just one who speaks for votes in his next run for a well paid position as State Senator. I am really, really touched that he named his son William---as he points out in his letter to the editor---because of the strength of his beliefs in equality and thus in honor of Justice William Brennan. Unfortunately it is, to me, a pile of dung... On the former, maybe he is pandering to the constituencies in Norristown, Bridgeport, and the left-leaning Radnor and Haverford folks... On the latter, maybe he just didn't want to saddle his son with the name Daylin Leach, Jr. so that as the young man worked his way through life he was not saddled with the sins of his father...

November 3, 2011 at 8:46 PM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I love it---Leach threw it right back in Spencer's face. I don't doubt that Spencer would have been best friends with Wallace,given the chance. Jake learns well from his father---making fun of a name just because you disagree with the guy---Springton Lake educated? The Daily Times loves these mediocre writers: Spencer,Gebhart,Zoren. Bring back the syndicated guys---send these others back to Towntalk! Who is Spencer fooling--this is all a cover for tearing down public schools--supporting vouchers--typical Republican line--like he cares about poor black children (what about poor white childen)!

November 4, 2011 at 7:07 AM 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home